Advertisers — what happens when ‘quality media’ crosses the line?

Photo by Tara Winstead from Pexels

An extract from my interview with John McCarthy at The Drum on advertising funding hate and disinformation, read the full interview here.

In an ad-funded web, big bucks from brands make a lot of disinformation sources profitable. Brands are awakening to this. Advertisers should “treat advertising spend like a resource to incubate and fund a healthy internet”. This means defunding/blocking the “bad stuff” and including quality journalism with inclusion lists.

Now, not all journalism is born equal, and what passes as “quality” is open to debate. It’s a gray area…

But for brands talking a big game on inclusion and diversity, does spending in media that argues against these ideals erode the sincerity of their initiatives? Does a couple of news stories featuring hate or misinformation sully a huge media brand? How much control should advertisers exhibit over media titles they buy in?

These are all questions marketers must ask themselves and Kingaby says it’s important that advertisers challenge these publications when they cross the line. “And if they pause spend [after a particularly controversial story], it is important to have a dialogue about why.”

“Freedom of speech doesn’t mean you get the automatic right to be paid for that speech. I can stand in a field and say whatever I like, but I don’t have the automatic right to be paid for saying it.”

“If you turn a blind eye and keep fueling the beast, the beast can come back to bite you. We have a hugely polarized electorate and that’s not good for business.”

Mozilla Fellow and co-chair of the Conscious Advertising Network. Advertising, ethics, AI and climate change. Yes, they do go together.

Love podcasts or audiobooks? Learn on the go with our new app.

Recommended from Medium

Is it Mobile first — Desktop second for the Publishing industry?

Propaganda Effects explained in“The Fake News Fallacy” and shown by“War of the Worlds”

Are Native Ads Killing Real Journalism?

Ad-centric revenue models will always create a race to the bottom

Is Modern News too Surface-Level to Promote Change?

Did Mixed Messages from the Media Drive the Covid-19 Resurgence?

If I’m an Expert, Something is Wrong

Women’s Room: Why does Vital Speeches still publish so many speeches by men?

Get the Medium app

A button that says 'Download on the App Store', and if clicked it will lead you to the iOS App store
A button that says 'Get it on, Google Play', and if clicked it will lead you to the Google Play store
Harriet Kingaby

Harriet Kingaby

Mozilla Fellow and co-chair of the Conscious Advertising Network. Advertising, ethics, AI and climate change. Yes, they do go together.

More from Medium

How to Be More than “10% Happier” ᵀᴹ

Learning Through Teaching: How behavior change expertise can guide corporate accessibility…

Think Micro-services, but don’t think Micro and don’t think Services

Managing Large Backlogs — lessons from the trenches